St. Michael's church contains many fine works of art, including some of the most important ecclesiastical works of Tiffany Glass Studios founded by Louis Comfort Tiffany. The interior decorations by Tiffany and others were added in stages after the completion of the current church building in 1891.

St. Michael's contains many other fine examples of stained glass by other leading artists, which were added by parishioners over the years to adorn the church. These include windows by important American stained glass designers J&R Lamb and Maitland Armstrong. The addition of stained glass windows culminated in 1926-7 with nine windows by Charles J. Connick Studios of Boston.

The interior of the church was painted with brilliant colors in 1990 by Fine Art Decoration of New York. For most of its first 100 years, the sanctuary had been painted in neutral colors. In celebration of its centennial, the church was repainted using colors in the palette of the Tiffany decorations.

Art
Tiffany Windows
Architecture